12 Reviews of Chocolate Chip Peanut Butter Oat Cookies

From: Preachers Wife

On Sep 12, 2005

These were amazing! My husband actually said they may be the best cookie he has ever had!

From: 89240

On May 8, 2004

Woah, these are dangerous. You won't be able to stop eating them! I only made half a recipe because I had 1 cup of chocolate chips. The first day I made them, they were just okay, not spectacular, but the second day, they were 5 times better! They seemed a bit chewier, and richer. I'm not sure why, but next time I'll make them a day ahead of time. They don't have a strong peanut butter taste, the chocolate flavor is more dominant. Have a big glass of milk ready for these!

From: shimmerchk

On May 1, 2004

Wow, these were delicious! I was skeptical about the oatmeal as well, but it gives the cookie a great texture. You will find that these cookies come out soft on the inside, slightly crisp around the edges with a nice bit of chewiness to the texture. The flavor was wonderful and the cookies spread just a little bit, but still end up looking very nice and not too flat. The measuring was super simple and the batter was quick to make. My two year old even liked these and she usually won't touch anything with oatmeal in it. My husband, a self-proclaimed choco chip cookie connoisseur, said these were terrific. I love it when a recipe gives results beyond our expectations, and this cookie certainly did just that. Thanks so much for sharing the recipe!

From: 3laroques

On Jun 2, 2004

I have to say that unlike everyone else, these were not as good as I expected! I really like chocolate chip cokies, oatmeal, and peanut butter, and was really excited about these cookies. The flavor is good, but the texture just isn't for me, and I think the oatmeal leaves them too dry. I tried baking some longer and some less, but it didn't seem to make a difference. Maybe I had my hopes up too high? Good cookies overall-even bad cookies are usually good!-but not as good as they could have been.

From: KristinB

On May 19, 2004

Delicious!!! Everyone loved them & they were gone very quickly. I'll definitely make these again & again!! Thanks for sharing!!

From: Sassy Sandra

On May 5, 2004

Very yumpy. I made the recipe to the tee, and it worked great. My kids gobbled these little cookies up, just like a bunch of turkeys! Thanks very much for the great recipe!

From: Marsha Lynn

On Jun 9, 2004

Absolutely fantastic and simple. They combine the best of so many great ingredients. My friend tried the recipe and also added chopped pecans.

From: CrystalA

On May 4, 2004

I really like these. I dont care for chocolate and PButter together. But these had just a slight hint of PButter. The texture came out like a peanut butter cookie does, which I like. They were soft, not gooey, and chewy.

From: Torricus

On Feb 20, 2008

Absolutely delicious! They're the perfect pick-me-up at the end of a not-so-great day! They're a fantastic texture, and just the right balance of peanut butter, chocolate, and oats. I almost couldn't bear to dunk them in milk!

From: cookingmother

On Sep 13, 2008

I made these cookies today and they are delicious. I think they are very moist; they didn't get dry on me as a lot of peanut butter cookies have. I used crunchy peanut butter because that's what I had. I love the "random recipe" feature, I've found some wonderful recipes with it, including these cookies. Thanks for sharing!