7 Reviews of Kinda Amish Macaroni Salad

From: * Pamela *

On Apr 17, 2005

Thank you! Thank you! I have always tried to recreate the creamy pasta salads that the deli sells and I have always been unsuccessful...until now! This salad is fabulous and I will be making it often this summer. I made this for our first family BBQ of the season and I served this with Cola Burgers Cola Burgers The only change that I made was to use shell shaped pasta instead of macaroni. Thanks for posting

From: Little T

On Apr 25, 2007

Yummy! This was really good. I chopped the celery, carrots, and onions fine per the instructions, but next time I will leave the celery in bigger chunks to give the salad a little more texture variety. Excellent flavor! Thanks for posting!

From: ThatDebbieGirl

On May 31, 2004

I was looking up Amish Macaroni Salad since that was my assignment for today\'s picnic......and right here you were sis! You\'re always there to help me out! I left out the carrot and only used 5 eggs since that is all I had. The taste is great for a Weber family picnic. Not fancy, just plain yummy! My husband added salt to his.........

From: VA

On Sep 22, 2006

Made this today for my guys to take to camp. The only thing I changed was to add less sugar (I put a little over 1/4 cup in) and it is outstanding! Used my food processor to chop the veggies and it went together in a snap. I chopped 7 eggs in the salad and sliced 3 on the top. Thanks for sharing.

From: sybrsuzy

On Aug 2, 2005

This macaroni salad is delicious. Three of us "ate the whole thing" in a couple of days. I made the eggs into big chunks but will make smaller ones next time--just personal preference. Thanks, ThatBobbieGirl!

From: Chef #1099893

On Jun 23, 2009

From: Sheri-BDB

On Jan 21, 2006

This is a great macaroni salad! It turned out nice and creamy and tasted great. I think the eggs must make it more creamier. Its a keeper. Thanks ThatBobbieGirl....