15 Reviews of 3 Ingredient Ice Cream Sandwich Cake

From: Troop Angel

On Aug 16, 2004

This was so easy to prepare...the hardest part is crumbling the Oreos! The only problem I had was keeping it together when I tried to cut it; I probably should have let it sit out for a few minutes to soften. But it still tasted great!! Thanks for such a "cool" recipe!

From: Heather Reynolds in Virginia

On Jun 11, 2007

I saw the photo and couldn’t resist making it however I didn’t have any chocolate whipped cream on hand SOO I used a container of cool whip mixed with about 1/4 cup whipping cream and some powdered chocolate milk mix. You could probably just use milk; it just needs a little liquid to dissolve the chocolate milk mix. I then following the directions as written and I ended up with a frosted cake looking like dessert with Oreo’s all over the top and sides...Yummy...The whipped cream mixture just spread really nice all over the dessert so i decided to just go with it. When we cut the dessert it was BEAUTIFUL!!! I will make sure I pick up a can of chocolate whipped cream for next time to have on hand because this is one Heck of an Easy Dessert that I would give 10 stars if I could. Its very elegant looking and a keeper for sure. Thank you so much Sherri for this one

From: internetnut

On Jun 5, 2007

I have not tried this recipe. My copy of this recipe is slightly different it calls for chocolate or white whipped cream, 10oz bag candy coated chocolate or peanut butter pieces. Variations Vary candy colors and choices to represent holidays or special occasions throughout the year. Use birthday candles with holders for a special birthday cake. Use two layers of two sandwiches each, and let kids assemble their own creations. Thanks for posting. Christine (internetnut)

From: **Mandy**

On Mar 22, 2007

Yum, Didn't have any chocolate whipped cream so just used vanilla & was still great. Have since bought chocolate ready to make this again, simple & delicious!!

From: Kohtzy

On Jun 29, 2007

Yummy! we made this with Reeses PB Cups and halved the recipe (2 sandwiches on each level)since it was just for my DH and I to share. It was great, and next time we will definitely make the full recipe. Thanks!

From: Roxygirl in Colorado

On Feb 22, 2009

I invited some neighbors over for the first time and was unsure what to make for dessert. I chose this orig. for the kids and planned to make another dessert for the adults. After I made this and saw how fabulous it looked (and that it would serve all 9 of us), I decided not to make the other. Thanks so much for saving me the time! I used Oreos and reg. whipped cream and fretted that it may not look as fancy as the choc., but it looked GREAT. I decorated the sides of the bars with some piped whipped cream and added a nice star (dollop) on top, and it gave it an extra finish. I would like to try other flavors of ice cream sandwiches, too. This was a hit with ALL and made me looked GOOD, even though I knew it had taken just a couple of min. It reminded me of the Nabisco Refrigerator Cake that we love, just with thicker layers. A PERFECT choice for entertaining. Thank you Sherri! Roxygirl

From: JackieMarie

On Aug 5, 2003

From: Chef #494084

On Oct 20, 2007

Made this for a baby shower and got rave reviews! COuld not be easier and wow was it good! I used chocolate cool whip instead of the can whip cream and it was awesome!

From: FCR Gal

On Aug 18, 2007

Someone brought one of these to work, so I went looking for a recipe when we were having company. I used a mixture of ice cream sandwiches with chocolate and vanilla ice cream. Could not be any easier to make, but has a nice presentation. Everyone screams for ice cream!

From: beth

On Dec 5, 2005

Made this with crushed Reese cups! OMG! Used chocolate Redy Whip(2 cans). I covered the entire cake with the whipped cream as if frosting. I would make sure to use a quality sandwich as well. Really, really good!!!!!