5 Reviews of Watermelon Salad

From: rsarahl

On Jun 21, 2003

I made this salad twice because I the result I got the first time was disappointing and I was just sure that a little tweaking would make the difference. The first go, I used room temp watermelon, canned jalapeno and dried parsley. I poured the vinagrette on the salad about 10 minutes before serving and the result was a soggy, slightly broken down salad with dull flavor that needed a good douse of salt and pepper. 2nd go round I prepared it with ice cold watermelon, fresh parsley and fresh jalapeno and the result was a salad with nice contrasts of cold, sweet melon with little spicy bites of jalapeno, and very refreshing mint. The fresh/raw ingredients make the flavor of this salad lively and the color and flavor just burst! We didn't find much salt necessary at all the 2nd time, but did use a couple grinds of fresh cracked pepper.

From: ellie_

On Jul 18, 2003

Wonderful refreshing salad for summer! I never heard of watermelon in salad for anything but fruit salad before, but we all loved this salad and will be having this often during the summer. Thanks Chia for sharing this recipe.

From: PaulaG

On Jul 5, 2005

This is a wonderfully refreshing salad for the summer. I used ice cold watermelon, fresh mint and fresh jalapenos. I did not have the fresh parsley; however, did have cilantro and it worked very well. I poured the dressing over just before serving. It was a nice accompaniment to the lentil soup I served it with.

From: Chefly

On Aug 11, 2008

Chia, This salad is excellent! I normally tweak almost every recipe I make but not this one. It is perfect just as it is. I do suggest adding the watermelon to the dressing mixture just before serving so the watermelon doesn't exude juices and thin the dressing. Thank you for posting this keeper.

From: JeriBinNC

On Jul 15, 2007

I made this to take to a potluck picnic, and it was a huge hit. I left out the parsley, cut the oil down to 2 tablespoons, and I used white wine vinegar because that's what I had on hand. It tasted best when it was ice cold, but it was quite good even at room temperature. I'm a sucker for salads that combine sweet and savory flavors anyway, but this one combines them very well! I'll make this one again; thanks for posting!