6 Reviews of Magic Pie

From: Terrilynn

On Oct 16, 2002

This was truely Magic. So quick and easy to prepare with just several on hand ingredients. I was amazed at how it makes its own crust. I followed the amount of ingredients and instructions without any alterations, using the crushed pineapple. I found two things I would do differently the next time. I would use two cups of crushed pineapple instead of one to enhance the pineapple flavor. With only one cup it had the wonderful light fluffy taste of an egg custard and not quite enough pineapple taste. I also found that after the 40 minute cooking time was up, the middle of the pie was no where near set but the edges were getting very brown. I covered the edges with aluminum foil and had to bake for another 40 minutes before it set. I will have to check my oven as the temperature may be off. It was wonderful, light, tasty and super easy and I will add it to my favorites.

From: Mar~Bear

On Dec 5, 2005

This is a magic pie! I used coconut. Makes a very pretty pie,and very easy to make.( a no brainer)

From: WI Cheesehead

On Jan 1, 2007

This is a great kitchen science experiment for the kids. The "magic" of chemistry. I have a similar recipe that uses 1/4 C honey instead of sugar 1/3 C butter (or margarine), so it's probably a little healthier. My recipe says, "measure everything into a blender, turn on high speed and count to 10." How much easier can that get?

From: Bev

On Nov 5, 2007

This may be the easiest pie I have ever made! I used shredded coconut for an extremely tasty coconut pie! No crust to make because this recipe does indeed develop it's own crust as it bakes. My pie was ready in exactly 37 minutes and I garnished with toasted coconut. Lee Lee, I love you and miss you so much! Your legacy lives on in all the incredible recipes you passed down to me ~ Thank you for being my Mom : )

From: tropics48

On Oct 22, 2002

From: Deb K*

On Jun 30, 2009

Needs sugar. I added 1/2 cup. You can also cut the butter back a bit. It took about an hour to bake.