14 Reviews of Peanut Butter Pie

From: MackinacBride

On Sep 20, 2002

OH MY!!!! This was yummy!! My picky husband and his friend finished off the entire pie in 45 minutes!! I got one little slice and it was to die for! A big glass of milk is a must with this pie as it is very sweet! I used more peanut butter than what the recipe called for 'cause I wanted to finish off the jar, but other than that I followed this very quick, simple recipe exactly!

From: Gingerbear

On Sep 20, 2002

This pie is wonderful, Inez. I loved it. This is definitly a keeper. This is honestly one of the best pies that I have ever tasted. So creamy and peanut buttery and the chopped peanuts on top make it even more delicious. Thank you for a great recipe. I will definitly be making this again and again.

From: PaigeParkerMomma

On Sep 10, 2002

Thanks! I have been looking for a good and easy peanut butter pie recipe. My favorite pie is peanut butter. I look forward to fixing this pie for my family.

From: Cookbook Barbie

On Jun 19, 2003

My husband went nuts over this! He loves anything chocolate and peanut butter. I, too, used reduced- or low-fat ingredients, with excellent results. Thanks!

From: Natalie Z

On Aug 1, 2003

Joy abounds with this delicious pie. I love peanut butter the way most women love chocolate. This pie was creamy, rich and so sinful I will have to run an extra 3 miles this week. I will keep this for special occasions. Thanks MizzNezz.

From: Ladybug II

On Dec 25, 2002

Delicious! I made two of these for Christmas Dinner. I did use reduced fat peanut butter, fat free cream cheese and fat free cool whip.. Tasted wonderful@

From: oriana

On Oct 7, 2004

I would never of thought to have peanut butter in a cheesecake like pie. I didn't have a premade crust so I made one using peanut butter oreos and butter.

From: Shelli

On Aug 29, 2003

This was wonderful!!!! I will make it again and again! I didn't have any chopped peanuts so I topped it with crushed oreo cookies......it was sinfully delicious!

From: MICHELLE burgard

On Aug 13, 2003

AWESOME!!!! How can something so simple turn out soo fabulous. This is my all time favorite pie!!! I actually used a nutty bar crust because i didnt have a premade one or chocolate cookies so i used about 4 nutty bars and about 3 tbs of butter and froze it for 10 mins and then poured on the peanut butter filling. This would also taste great with chocolate pudding or more whipped topping as another layer!!!!

From: Messy Kitchen Maid

On Jun 23, 2006

very good,not too heavy.