9 Reviews of Top Secret! Wendy's Frosty

From: Sharon123

On Apr 19, 2009

Well, YUM! My DH just raved over this easy to make drink! I ended up using malted chocolate powder. Now he wants one every night! Thanks kitty! Made for 123 Hit Wonders tag.

From: Andi of Longmeadow Farm

On Apr 2, 2009

Funny, I was requesting Spring to start the spring around here, and I conjured up a dream about vanilla ice cream. So while that was churning I found this tasty, ever so lovely frosty recipe to try to endure through. (laughing here!) And endure you must. I followed this exactly. There would be nothing to change here, the flavors burst with freshness, chocolate was so yummy I almost fainted from waiting so long to eat. Next time (and there will be!) I might add some instant coffee granules (a few) and make it like a coffee mocha, although presented in this fashion is just perfect! Made for Everyday is a Holiday April 2009

From: Blue Peacock

On Apr 3, 2009

kittycatmom, I have had this recipe for years but never made it until now. My 7-year-old said that he wants a chocolate milkshake, and having this specific recipe, I thought to try it. It was rich and creamy. I had vanilla bean ice cream which is intense in vanilla flavor, and had to add a little more Nestle's Quik. This one is a keeper. Thank you for sharing.

From: HokiesLady

On Apr 12, 2009

Wowzers!!!! When I tagged this in 123 Hits I thought initially it would be just like a regular milkshake but lo and behold this actually tastes just like a Wendy's Frosty. Nice and thick and a wonderful flavor! Never again will I spend over a dollar for a Frosty at their restaurant when I can make one at home without all the "junk" for half the cost! Thanks for sharing this WINNER!!

From: Lauralie41

On Nov 23, 2009

DH always gets a frosty when we go to Wendy's and he said this was close in flavor to the original. Also a tasty inexpensive treat! Thank you sweets for sharing this recipe with us. Made and reviewed for KK's Recipe Tag Game.

From: Lorrie in Montreal

On Apr 25, 2009

Made for holiday tag. If I could rate this higher I would.Simple and oh so yummy even with the Brain Freeze I developed due to my greediness...lol.

From: diner524

On Jul 10, 2009

Yummy chocolate shake!!! It tastes similar to a Wendy's Frosty and is just delicious on a hot summer day!!! Thanks for sharing the recipe. Made for your win in the Summer Spectacular!!!

From: 2Bleu (Bird&Buddha)

On May 5, 2009

This is really good! It tasted somewhat like a Wendy's frosty, but irregardless, it's a great shake recipe. Thanks for sharing.

From: eggsnbakin

On May 3, 2009

It was really good, but it tasted more like a chocolate shake than a frosty. I followed the recipe...it was good.