16 Reviews of M&m Cookies

From: Sherri35

On Sep 6, 2003

Very good! The cookies turned out a golden brown and nice and chewy. The only change I made was to add 1 tsp. of baking soda because I thought it was a little odd that it didn't call for any. Thanks for a great cookie recipe!

From: TLashier

On Feb 14, 2004

Just made a batch for Valentine's Day Bake Sale. Used the idea of putting more of the red, pink and white M&M's on top, and they not only taste great, but look great, too. Good recipe!

From: Baker*Chick

On Feb 10, 2003

Yummy! I used 3/4 c. butter flavored Crisco stick instead of butter. Very Good! Thanks for sharing.

From: cooking_geek

On Dec 6, 2003

These were good cookies too! I also added some baking soda to the recipe and I chilled my dough because I have a problem with a hot kitchen!

From: RecipeNut

On Apr 5, 2004

These were wonderful! Came out golden and nice and chewy. Keeper in my house. Thanks Carole

From: mtnbaker

On Aug 15, 2007

Baked these exactly as written; they did turn out chewy and nicely browned, but found the next day that they are incredibly salty and a little bland. Would probably add baking soda and 1/2 tsp salt next time.

From: AlexandriaAngel

On Apr 26, 2004

excellent flavor, but I substituted white sugar and 2 tbs of mollasses,because I didnt have any brown sugar. Still came out wonderful!

From: Brandy K Hambright

On Oct 19, 2003

Loved this recipe. Even my fiance who can only boil water can make these. He know's their my favorite. Some people get flowers I need cookies.

From: martini2

On Dec 29, 2003

My DH loves these! I made them for Christmas cookies keeping the green and red ones out, and after spooning onto cookie sheet placing the green and red ones on top before baking. My DH made sure there were enough left for him while I was making the cookie gift plates!

From: dancer jules

On Dec 10, 2003

Great Recipe!!! My 4 year old and I have made these cookies twice in the last 2 weeks. Very easy! I used exactly what the recipe called for and they were amazing! Thanks for sharing Carole!