32 Reviews of Tinker's Cuddy / Homemade Frosty Paws

From: Bogey'sMom

On Apr 22, 2002

Make that 4 out of 4 dogs, because my three loved this. I love to cook for my children without fur, so it's nice to find things I can fix for my fur-bearing children. Three year old Isaiah and one year old Ishmael were sleeping while I made this, so the baby dog, 6 month old Bogey, got to lick the bowl. He loved it not frozen, but the three of them had a frozen version this afternoon and it got a definite "paws up". Thanks for sharing.

From: Mille® ™

On May 4, 2002

5 out of 5 dogs! My Norwegian Elkhound went (alnost literally) crazy, attacking it like a freshly killed rabbit or something - it was quite amusing to watch. So this one gets a thumbs up for the doggie taste factor, and another thumbs up for the human entertainment value!

From: Indiana Debbie

On Mar 17, 2003

Easy to make and thoroughly enjoyed by Skipper,the most beautiful chocolate lab.Take Elmo's advice about serving them outside.

From: Gingerbear

On Apr 27, 2003

I made these for my dogs yesterday and they loved them. I just picked them up yesterday from getting neutered and felt that I should make them something good so that they would still like me. Great recipe! I even tasted the ingredients before I froze them and not bad . Thank you for a great recipe. I will be making these again!

From: seahorse73

On Jun 29, 2003

I made these yesterday for Sambuca, and now in the heatwave in NY, she is loving it! Thanks!

From: Koshka

On Nov 9, 2007

I have been making these for my dogs for awhile and have another hint. My dogs will eat the paper cups so I freeze put the mixture in to different size muffin/cupcake pans and put those directly in to the freezer. When they are frozen I pop them right out with a butter knife and bag them in big ziplock baggies. When serving them I simply place the frosty paw in a coffee cup and let them eat it that way!

From: MaryMeow

On Aug 13, 2003

I made these for my favorite puppies, Fred and Emma, and they loved them! They gobbled them up! They are Large Dogs, so I made the pupsicles in plastic cups. It seemed to take a long time to thaw, the dogs kept licking them, but they were to hard to bite into. Next time, I will use smaller size dixie cups. I really liked this recipe because you know exactly what the dogs are eating, good ingredients, no fillers! Thanks, I will make this again!

From: Michelle S.

On Nov 14, 2002

My 2 black standard poodles, Emeril and Giovanni LOVE you for this. Me too! Sure beats driving to Dairy Queen to get them a baby cone!

From: Melslack

On Dec 13, 2003

My pups love this! I made it with Bonzo's Bodacious Bundt cake for their birthday. I had two wagging happy tails. It freezes quite firm-you may want to leave it out for a few minutes before serving, or defrost in the microwave for 15-20 seconds.

From: Pianolady

On Aug 2, 2004

My oh my! My dog, Frosty, just went crazy over these! He loves Frosty Paws, so I was hopeful that these would get a good reaction, but I was not prepared for how much he did like them. He carried the cup away by the rim whenever we got close to him, as he was not about to share. He even got his nose stuck in the cup once in his exhuberance to get every last drop. Frosty says to give these treats 10 stars, but I have had to explain to him that 5 stars is the max... he doesn't seem to like that Thanks for this — I will always keep some in the freezer! Dianne