8 Reviews of Diet Coke Cake

From: Christineyy!

On May 6, 2007

I felt so much better eating this and it was really really fudgy! I was surprised that it actually had the texture of a regular chocolate cake!

From: Chef #198417

On Feb 13, 2008

I'm rating this 5 stars because it is an outstanding 'RV-ing'recipe: simple ingredients to mix and then bake in disposable pan. Wondering if diet 7-up and carrot cake mix would work?

From: WhirledPeas

On Apr 28, 2008

This worked out great for us! It does have a tendency to stick on your fingers if you make it into cupcakes so I would recommend wet wipes if you are packing it in a lunch I can't wait to try it with vanilla cake and other diet soda flavors. This will be great to keep me on track with WW, only less than 1 pt. for a small cupcake. YUM.

From: ceruleanseven

On Aug 6, 2007

Wonderful cake. It's been forever since I had chocolate cake, and this did not diappoint.

From: cookiemaker

On Dec 14, 2007

Well, this didn't really work for me. I couldn't get a toothpick to come out clean, even after more time, so I thought I'd just let it cool and see what happened. It's really gooey. I did realize that my oven maybe wasn't all the way up to 350 (what the box called for). Also, I used a reduced sugar mix (it contains Splenda), so that may have had something to do with it. Oh well. It doesn't have eggs in it, so we'll just eat it gooey like this. I made some glaze/frosting to put on top, just powdered sugar and milk and flavoring. I'm sure the cool whip frosting would be great, I just didn't have any. No stars, because I didn't quite follow the recipe. I may try it again sometime, with a regular cake mix, and be sure to have the oven exactly as high as it needs to be.

From: Chef #458063

On May 7, 2009

Very moist and light. I used diet cherry coke and made cupcakes. A good recipe for those of us watching calories.

From: MiMadre'

On Oct 1, 2008

Sorry it took so long to review this but I took this wonderful concept and ran with it. I used a lemon cake mix, and a can of sugar free ready to drink lemonade (Minute Maid). For the icing I used the Cool Whip lite and added a small box of sugar free lemon pudding. Yummy! I didn't tell anyone they were eating "diet", there wasn't a bite left. I can't wait to try other combinations. Thanks for a great recipe.

From: Teri AZ

On Jun 25, 2009

Used diet sprite and white cake mix with pudding in the mix - it turned out horrible! Sticky and not cake like at all. I ended up throwing the whole cake out!