5 Reviews of Amish Peanut Butter

From: clowneygirl

On Oct 14, 2007

I love this stuff. I grew up in a small town in northern Indiana (Shipshewana) and I was raised on this. This was the peanut butter that we always had on sandwiches at school even. My mom always made sure to keep lots of it on hand. I haven't had it in a long time. My mom passed away and I never could find her recipe. I thought I knew what was in it but not sure of the amounts. Thank you so much for posting this.

From: mandikaake

On Jun 20, 2005

Ok now that I've made this it's GREAT. Tastes just like the stuff I buy in Shipshewana at the Amish stores and so easy to make! I think I'm going to give this away for Christmas gifts along with homemade wheat bread. THanks!

From: Sandi G.

On Mar 31, 2007

My sister married an amish fellow when I was younger. His mother made this for us and I remember this recipe tasting just like hers. This is the best recipe. I love it. Easy to make and yummy!!!

From: JanuaryBride

On Jul 1, 2009

Not the recipe I was looking for, but WOW is this fantastic!!! Put some on graham crackers. Gonna buy some chocolate ice cream and use it as a topper tomorrow (I'll get a photo then). Delicious!!!!!

From: Andtototoo!

On Sep 30, 2009

Very easy! Thanks.