12 Reviews of Irish Chicken and Dumplings

From: Cindy Lynn

On Sep 20, 2002

Rather than use chicken breast halves, I used chicken wings (I freeze big bags of them for chicken stock/stews when we butcher), which I cooked up this morning. When I was ready to complete the Chicken and Dumplings, I removed the chicken wings and picked the meat off the bones, measured out the broth in the pan...couldn't believe it was exactly the three cups called for...wouldn't have happened if I'd been trying...lol. I added the remaining ingredients, including the de-boned chicken and cooked as directed. I could not find my bag of frozen peas in either chest freezer or fridge freezer, so I substituted canned peas (it would definitely have been even better with fresh or frozen) instead. I made up some bisquits and dropped them in. I must have made them a little larger than the recipe called for because I had to cook them a little longer than stated (approximately 10 minutes). With the creamed soups added so early (with raw potatoes and carrots), I expected it to tend to stick and possibly scorch...not a bit though (yeaaaahhh). We all really enjoyed this and will definitely be having it again. There were only 3 of us for dinner tonight, so we had about half left over, which is great because I need something to just warm up tomorrow evening. Since we don't like reheated dumplings, I removed the remaining ones before refrigerating the left-overs and will make fresh tomorrow evening. Thanks for sharing a really great recipe RecipeNut. I just had to try this when I saw Irish since 50% of my heritage is Irish!

From: Boca Pat

On May 4, 2004

What a great recipe this is. I used a whole chicken, but there was so much meat that I only used about half of it for this recipe. It was so easy to make and had such a great taste. My dumplings even came out perfect!!! I'm not known for my dumplings!!!!!!! I had about 1/2 bag of baby carrots that I threw in too. Simple and delicious, that's how I rate this one. Thanks RecipeNut.

From: Happy Hippie

On Mar 8, 2007

Awesome chicken and dumplings that was enjoyed by the whole family. The changes I made were as follows: used leftover chicken breasts, cut in chunks. Since chicken was not stewed for broth, I used low sodium chicken broth instead of water. Also, I used 2 cans of condensed cream of chicken and mushroom soup rather than cream of chicken soup as called for in the recipe. I also added a teaspoon of chopped garlic and only one onion chopped rather than quartered. the cooking time was greatly reduced also due to the use of leftover chicken. Total cooking time for this recipe as I prepared it was about 50 minutes. These are fairly minor adaptions to an already perfect quick and easy recipe. Thanks RecipeNut for a meal that will be served in our home again and again.

From: VA

On Apr 3, 2004

This is an awesome recipe! Easy and delicious. I have been making it for years and my family loves it. This is our all-time favorite comfort food.

From: Hugce

On Dec 8, 2003

RecipeNut...this is a keeper. Made it yesterday it was awsome. I didn't have 2 cans of Cream of chicken Soup, so I used one can and one can of cream of mushroom. also used chicken tenders and didn't shred it, left them whole. the dumplings were the best. Thanks again.

From: Tarlain

On Aug 8, 2005

I made a double batch. I used my largest Dutch oven. it almost did not fit. Some of the dumplings actually stuck to the lid. I had to cook the dumplings about an extra 20 mins since I double the recipe. The whole family loved it. Even my neices the are very picky. I was able to bag and store another 7 servings for lunch for the next week.

From: pasmaszek

On Aug 27, 2009

From: Trish Za Dish

On Aug 30, 2009

Born, raised and living in western Canada. I've never had any 'chicken and dumplings' dish until today. It was okay. I used cream of mushroom soup and I know it wouldn't have made that much of a difference. The addition of the veggies is in perfect timing. All come out cooked just right. This is good. I used chicken thighs and they are very flavorful. It was a good dish, though, for the amount of time and prep I'm not sure that I will make it again. My 8 yo daughter also gives it a 3 star. Just like any comfort food if you grow up with it there is a world of difference in how you like it. I grew up with Ukrainian food as a staple and I know there are people who don't care much for cabbage rolls or borscht. This dish is in one of those.... a borscht. I think it's very good and I'm glad I tried it, it's just not amazing enough to give 5 stars for my 'comfort.'

From: NELady

On Sep 1, 2008

First, this makes a TON of food. It easily fed six, and I still had a slew of left overs. Second, it is simple to throw together and serve, and it has familiar flavors that everyone at my table likes. I followed the recipe as stated except I served with Red Lobster Cheese Biscuits (Red Lobster Cheese Biscuits) instead of dumplings. Also served with fresh cobbed corn and peaches. I will make this again, might half the recipe as needed.

From: QueenJellyBean

On Sep 23, 2008

I thought this was pretty good! I think that 3 cups of chicken broth opposed to water would give it a richer taste and so will do that next time. I cut the chicken into bite sized pieces and chopped the onion, potatoe and carrots. Other than that it was really good and my family liked it. Perfect winter time comfort food!