37 Reviews of Fluffer Nutter Sandwich

From: Sharlene~W

On Apr 1, 2002

My kids love these. They are a change of pace from the usual PB&J or peanut butter and honey sandwiches.

From: TheDancingCook

On Feb 6, 2002

I love this sandwich! Some people look at me weird when I mention this; they know the sandwich combo but not by the "Fluffer Nutter" name.

From: LIIT_Guy

On Feb 6, 2002

Just like Mom use to make for me after school for a snack. Sure does bring back good memories.

From: Melly2

On Jan 3, 2003

AAHH! Brings back sweet memories! I add sliced bananas too and it's oooh so yummy!

From: Bogey'sMom

On Apr 25, 2002

My husband is a die hard fluffer nutter fan. He would argue passionately with you that marshmallow creme is NOT the same as fluff. I personally had never heard of Fluff until I met him and I can't tell the difference. Fluff must be a yankee version of marshmallow creme.

From: Mark O.

On Apr 30, 2002

Actually "fluff" is just marshmallow creme with more air added in to the mix. Of course adding more air would make it taste different a little. Here is a link to take a look at, http://www.marshmallowfluff.com/htm/welcome.shtml . Mark :o) "He would argue passionately with you that marshmallow creme is NOT the same as fluff."

From: mermaidmagic

On Aug 29, 2004

OMG How funny! Who would have thought of posting this sandwich??? I never knew that fluffernutters weren't as common as pbj or tunafish. I found out recently that many people have never tried nor even heard of them. Yikes! I grew up on these and it's still a regular lunch in my home. Not just for my kids though - for me!

From: bmcnichol

On Apr 24, 2009

This was one of my favorite sandwiches growing up. I was never much of a PBJ fan but love PBM sandwiches. My kids now love these too. I do not measure the ingredients- I just spread them on.

From: Cookiegirlandi

On Mar 3, 2007

I like it on toast

From: Kathy in Fla

On Jun 29, 2005

I had never heard of this till I got married. It has been an old midnight snack stand-by since. This is even better if you toast it in oven. Spread PB on bread then cream on top of that. Place under broiler... Broil till cream is nice and toasty brown. WARNING ... let cool a little before eating... it does get hot!! Enjoy with a huge glass of milk!!