24 Reviews of Sea Salt Ice Cream

From: Omega the Zainin

On Aug 11, 2006

It's perfect. Kind of has the same salt-sweet taste of salt taffy. My suggestions: Paste food colouring seems to give it a much more vibrant colour. You can get it at cake stores, it's the kind used to dye frosting. I accidentally made one batch a bit too thin. I'm not sure how, I didn't do it any different than the rest. However, I was able to "fix" it by running it through the blender, adding a little confectioner's sugar to it and refreezing. It thickened up beautifully after that. But taste it before you freeze it after that, as the sugar will make it sweeter and you may want to throw in a bit more salt. For a bit of a fancy taste, put in some rose oil, too. Just a little bit will do it. Then again, I love that stuff and try to sneak it into everything! <3 This is quite good stuff. You really must try it.

From: Chef #937862

On Aug 30, 2008

It came out pretty well. There are just a few things I'd change around. If you're doing this all by hand/whisk (and I was), I recommend saving step two for during step six (edited). Instead of beating the egg whites right off the bat, I'd wait until you have some time to kill. It cuts down on prep time and you don't have to do it over again if it separates while you're cooking the custard. The other thing I'd change about this recipe is the lack of a clear measurement on how much sea salt to put in. I didn't measure how much I put in and it turns out it wasn't enough. When I tasted the final product, it was only just a little saltier than regular French Vanilla ice cream. Two tips I'd give as well: 1. Have friends around to work on multiple steps at once. We cut down on a lot of prep time because we had extra hands. 2. When you're making the custard, you should turn the heat gradually lower as it thickens. It ended up boiling on me because I left it on medium heat a bit too long. 3. If your custard DOES end up boiling, or if your milk ends up getting a skin to it, just whisk it all back in at a rapid pace. It'll melt back into the mixture. 4. Pour the boiling milk slowly into the egg yolk/sugar mixture (which is supposed to be whisked until it's a smooth, pale yellow color) so as to avoid making an omelette. I went just a little too fast at some parts and ended up with little solid bits of egg yolk in the mixture. When I figure out how much sea salt you should put in for a really tasty treat, I'll let you know. Of course different people have different tastes, so any set amount should be tampered with at least a little until you get what's right for you. ~_^

From: Chef #1271115

On May 18, 2009

zOMG coming from one of the biggest KH otaku EVERRR....okay that's a lie, if you're a KH otaku you're pretty much on the same level as the rest of us. but it was delicious. my friends and i couldn't get it to a custard thickness; we had to choose between frozen-liquid ice cream or eggy-chunk-filled-ice cream. so we chose frozen-liquid, and it turned out fine, so if it doesn't get custardy-thick don't freak out ^^

From: Jaelyndari

On Jun 10, 2009

Made my first batch with this recipe last night. I decided to make a ServingX4 batch so I had adjusted all my measurements. I had issues when boiling the milk of the milk burning on the bottom slightly, leaving clumps of burnt milk in the mixture. I solved this by straining it before adding the egg whites and cooling it and it worked rather well, as well as made the mixture more creamy in texture, though ideas on fixing the burning would be nice. Turning the temperture down as the milk mixture thickens helps it alot. I also measured my sea salt as I added it to taste and found that for the listed size 1/2tsp of the sea salt is a perfect blend for starters. It is a 1:1 ratio of sweet:salty and can be altered once you have made it once and tasted it. The food coloring didnt want to mix in well, so I advise taking an electric mixer with a wisk attachment and running it on a very low setting for about a minute to get it all properly blended. Mine came out rather ice hard in freezing because of bad planning and I couldnt properly stir it as it froze, but the small sample bowl I made and could stir as it froze came out creamy and delicious. The recipe would be easier and probably better with an ice cream maker, but overall was simple to make and came out wonderfully.

From: deebrie

On Nov 18, 2009

This recipe was wonderful! I wound up using 1/2 tsp of sea salt and that was the perfect amount. I also didn't use green food coloring, as the yellow of the custard helped to turn it the perfect color. Great recipe!

From: Chef #1456175

On Nov 22, 2009

imma make it soon i hope its good and i would use 1/2 SALT so i does not ruin it first then keep adding salt to see what u like, cus its a matter of taste

From: House

On Nov 4, 2006

From: Chef #1331407

On Jul 21, 2009

From: WI Cheesehead

On Feb 25, 2008

We had mixed reviews on this, but I may have used a bit too much salt, as I wasn't sure how much to use and wasn't as careful as the recipe stated! My DD and I like it, the rest did not. I used skim milk and accidentally did step 9 & 10 before step 7, but it still turned out. Had to freeze it for 40 minutes in ice cream machine b4 it set up, but it turned out thick and creamy, even with the skim milk.

From: Chef #526252

On Jun 28, 2007

Fantastic! To get the sort of Popsicle style assortment shown in the game, you'll need a set of simple Popsicle molds. Just fill the molds and pop into the freezer after step 11! May break slightly in the molds, one out of my seven did.