21 Reviews of Cream Pie (Chocolate, Coconut, and Banana Variations)

From: Michelle Zawoysky

On Dec 21, 2006

OMG! I made this recipe and everyone loved it! I made the chocolate version but, I added 1 cup of chips instead of 1/2 cup. It was so rich and creamy.

From: Linda's Busy Kitchen

On Nov 25, 2007

I made the coconut and chocolate cream pies this year for Thanksgiving. They were perfect and everyone devoured them! I will be using this recipe in the future for sure! Thanks for sharing your special recipes with us Tammi! Linda

From: Chef #464115

On Mar 24, 2009

We loved the rich chocolate flavor of this pie! We also added some instant coffee with the chocolate chips - mocha pie is definitely delicious! One thing that was disappointing is that our pie didn't set up. It remained rather runny, though still delicious. I think this might be because I used lactose-free milk. Word to the wise: Use regular milk!!

From: Liara

On Feb 11, 2007

I love this recipe, it's so easy and tastes great! I made a chocolate banana cream pie. I did only use 1/2 cup of sugar and we all loved it. Thank you!

From: Anme

On Feb 27, 2007

Great recipe! I used the chocolate variations and it turned out perfect!

From: Hazeleyes

On Mar 10, 2007

Wonderful pie recipe! I made the coconut version, and sprinkled extra coconut on the meringue. I had to cook the filling longer than what was stated, but turned out perfect! Thanks for sharing. Hazeleyes

From: CrystalB

On Feb 2, 2007

I LOVE this recipe but had never tried to make it in the microwave before. Worked fantastic! I'll never use the stovetop method again!!

From: Joanne Brance

On Oct 20, 2006

This was so incredibly easy!!! And it was fun. The only change was I made the chocolate with 1cup of choc. chips. It tasted divine. Thank you so much!! We'll be trying the other variations soon.

From: Sookieblu

On Jul 5, 2006

Great recipe. I've been looking for a cream pie filling like this for awhile. The banana cream I made for the 4th of July was beautiful. It was so quick and easy with the microwave directions. The taste was great and the pie was gone before the fireworks even started! Thanks for posting.

From: saylaveev

On Oct 10, 2006

When I took my first bite I died and went to heaven Ha Ha. This was a huge success, and I'm sure that if we didn't have 3 giant pies to choose from that night we would have happily eaten it all. Simple too, I didn't have any accessible microwave containers so i did it stovetop with it just taking a little longer. Will definately make again.