40 Reviews of Sucking Cowboy / Buttery Nipple

From: Alisa Lea

On Nov 26, 2005

This is one of my all time favorite drinks. I usually don't bother with the layering tho. Just mix equal amounts of the two together in a glass and add ice. I just finished drinking one made with ChrisMc's Irish Cream (recipe # 30860) and my Homemade Butterscotch Schnapps (recipe # 141581). I think it's time for another!

From: Jac

On Feb 6, 2002

This is a fantastic drink. It's also good to double the quantities and sip over a load of ice as opposed to the tradditional 'shots'.

From: Fiona Murray

On Jan 22, 2002

I absolutely love this, but where I'm from it's called a shooting star - slightly more poetic, I think. I managed to get my mother and an elderly Scottish neighbour absolutely plastered on these without them realising what they were doing. It just tastes soooo good

From: aderendal

On Jun 22, 2004

It's a Slippery Nipple Yall! To layer it, first pour in the snapps then pour the baileys slowly down over the back part of a spoon, which you have inserted into the shot glass..I haven't had one of these in years and Ladies night out coming up soon! Yippee- I'll have to try and see if the bartender knows what a sucking cowboy is though!

From: jazzy joy

On Mar 28, 2002

Just a little tibit of info This is also called a Buttery Nipple

From: Bethany Taylor

On Jan 4, 2006

YUM! Tastes like Werther's cream caramel hard candies. DBF and I loved these.. thanks for sharing!

From: Diane B.

On Mar 10, 2005

This drink is wonderul, I like it very cold so I keep both bottles in the freezer so they are ready. This is called a buttery nipple where I come from too.

From: Malriah

On Jul 25, 2002

Warning to those that don't drink alot...Don't let the taste fool you! While they are yummy, they will also give you a heckuva buzz! In Denver they are called "Butter Babies"

From: mama's kitchen

On Apr 28, 2006

YEEHAAWW!! MY cowboy and I LOVED these! My fave drink to order when I am out! Loved it!

From: riffraff

On Jan 8, 2003

We call them Buttery Nipples here too but I think I will start calling them Sucking Cowboy, much more interesting. Good drink. I make it by the glass instead of by the shot.