3 Reviews of Scallop Cakes

From: Hey Jude

On Mar 5, 2006

This was such a nice change from the crab cakes that I'm always making for my husband and myself. I prepared this pretty much as written, though I used cilantro in place of the parsley. We had these with Key lime ginger mustard (store bought) mixed with a little mayo and it was delicious! Thanks Geema, this one's a keeper

From: BonnieZ

On Oct 4, 2007

The flavor of these is a definite five star, but although I left them chill for over five hours, I still had a problem with them holding together, and I think the recipe would benefit with a better binder than flour (breadcrumb or panko). I did cut the salt to 1/4 tsp for dietary reasons. This is definitely a recipe that I would make again, using a better binder, as the flavor was just wonderful. Thank you Geema for sharing the recipe.

From: BettyBaker1

On Dec 15, 2008

I found these to be very messy; they really didn't set up even with chilling I had to triple the flour in the recipe in order to make them into cakes. Also the flavor was very bland and needs something to give it zing.