9 Reviews of Coney Island Chili Sauce for Hot Dogs

From: MathMom.calif

On Jun 22, 2007

This was a good start for chili, but seems to me it needs more seasonings or something. I doubled the recipe and the package of meat I bought was 1.25 pounds of 96% lean beef. Plus I used just a touch less water than called for. Hubby still said it was "watery". I increased the chili powder (by small amounts) and ended up putting in some hot pepper sauce shortly before serving, and still felt it needed more. Something else. I like the ease of the recipe but will play with it a bit next time and try adding different things. Thanks for posting.

From: kiwidutch

On Jun 13, 2007

Loved it ! I had extra meat so my mixture was thicker than maybe the recipe intended, the flavour was good and it dissapeared fast. Please see my rating system: 4 stars for a yummy and versitile recipe. Thanks!

From: Sheri-BDB

On Feb 8, 2006

We really enjoyed this chili sauce on top of our hot dogs. Thanks ellie_....

From: Lauralie41

On Dec 11, 2005

My DH loves chili dogs and this sauce was a big hit with him! I did add a little more garlic and chili powder for our taste. Next time I make this I will double the recipe.

From: Lainey6605

On Jun 11, 2007

A delicious chili dog sauce that was simple to make. I will use this again. Made for ZWT3 2007.

From: domesticatedmom

On Jan 27, 2008

When I make mine which is basically the same ingred. you have I add refried beans and cayenne pepper for little heat.

From: bmcnichol

On Jul 26, 2009

I doubled this recipe but followed it as written. I did have to add more chili powder as we felt it needed more. I made this then but it in the crockpot with the hotdogs and took them to the race track for dinner. Everyone enjoyed them.

From: Mskitty84

On Apr 5, 2008

Hubby loved it!

From: acerast

On Jun 11, 2007

Good stuff ellie! It was simple and had good flavor. The kids gave it two thumbs up Thanks for a keeper! acerast