7 Reviews of Banana Ice Cream

From: Bev

On Jun 8, 2007

Very creamy and flavorful ice cream! Remember when making this that your end flavor will only be as intense as your bananas, so make sure the bananas you are are ripe! This is such a nice recipe, I think that when I make it again, I am going to add a fudge ripple when the ice cream begins to form and also perhaps a few toasted almonds or walnuts to make it taste more like a banana split! : ) Thank you for this lovely recipe, duonyte!

From: S3b4s

On Mar 19, 2009

I made this over a year ago and forgot to review it. This was the first ice cream I ever made, and I loved it, along with everyone who tried it. I added some vanilla extract just for extra depth of flavor. Another great way to do it is to add a split vanilla bean to the syrup.

From: Chef #1242117

On May 10, 2009

Smooth, rich and creamy! We used super ripe bananas like the recipe said, and used a simple syrup with lemon. It was a little more tart than most banan ice creams due to the extra lemon but still better than any store made ice cream I've ever tasted, even better than the premium brands.

From: ladydae

On Sep 28, 2006

This was soooo tasty, and it didn't go as hard-packed as some ice cream recipes, so it was easier to eat even after having been in the freezer for a week or two. Very strong banana flavour.

From: PaulaG

On Jul 12, 2009

So easy and delicious. I used 4 large very ripe bananas and Simple Syrup for the syrup. About 1/2 cup chopped pecans was added as the ice cream began to freeze. This was used to make ice cream sandwiches which were made with Slice and Bake Peanut Butter Cookies. Nothing like peanut butter, banana and nuts. Thanks for a great recipe that I am sure to make again.

From: Kyle Newton

On Aug 12, 2009

This has great banana flavor without having to add extract or liquer. I think the simple syrup really helps enhance the banana flavor which can be too subtle because it's so cold. Husband is a huge banana ice cream fan and says this is the best ever.

From: Lainey6605

On Jul 9, 2009

This is delicious! So flavorful and rich. Thanks for sharing! Made for Gimme 5 tag.