My Page
My Cookbooks
  • Main Cookbook
    Premium Members can have more than one cookbook in this list. They can keep private cookbooks just for organizing their recipes, or share them publicly with friends or the world. Learn more
My Account
Bookmark and Share

Add this recipe to your:

Send this recipe:

Nutrition Facts

Serving Size 1 (203g)

Recipe makes 6 servings

Calories 512
Calories from Fat 203 (39%)
Amount Per Serving %DV
Total Fat 22.6g 34%
Saturated Fat 9.7g 48%
Monounsaturated Fat 8.0g
Polyunsaturated Fat 3.5g
Trans Fat 0.0g
Cholesterol 133mg 44%
Sodium 314mg 13%
Potassium 328mg 9%
Total Carbohydrate 70.2g 23%
Dietary Fiber 1.2g 4%
Sugars 52.5g
Protein 8.2g 16%

detailed view...

how is this calculated?

Jolean's Butterscotch Pie, Pennsylvania Dutch Style

Recipe #128543 | 45 min | 30 min prep | add private note
Stacky5

By: Stacky5
Jul 3, 2005

This is a personal, absolute favorite of mine!!! Mom never would tell us where she got this recipe (which always made Dad raise one eyebrow...LOL!) And she never gave us girls the recipe while she was here --- it was something truly special to her as well, although I don't know exactly why. I found the old, yellowed, hand-written recipe hidden deep in her personal recipe box after she passed away... The taste and the texture of this pie is incredible, and I've never been able to match it — I've tried for 6 or 7 years to find a "quick" fix for this. But nope...Nothing doing. Gotta have this exact recipe!!! Once you have this, you'll never fully enjoy any other butterscotch pie!!! (I sound pretty serious, don't I?) LOL! No, seriously, the recipe looks a whole lot more complicated than it really is — super simple, just home-made! YUM!

SERVES 6 -8 (change servings and units)

Ingredients

  • 1/4 cup real butter
  • 1 cup light brown sugar, firmly packed
  • 4 tablespoons flour (fresh)
  • 2 cups whole milk
  • 3 large egg yolks, separate eggs (reserve whites for meringue topping)
  • 1/2 teaspoon pure vanilla extract
  • 1 pinch salt

  • 1 (9 inch)  pie crusts, prepared (baked and cooled)

meringue SEE RECIPE BELOW

Directions

  1. 1
    Preheat oven to 350°.
  2. 2
    Stir brown sugar and butter in a saucepan until butter melts and sugar dissolves. Cook 2-3 minutes longer on low-medium heat, and then remove from fire.
  3. 3
    Beat egg yolks.
  4. 4
    In separate large bowl, mix flour with 1/2 of milk, until smooth. Then add beaten egg yolks and salt and mix well. Blend remaining milk with this mixture.
  5. 5
    Add flour mixture to saucepan with sugar/butter mixture and cook on low/medium heat until thickened, stirring CONSTANTLY.
  6. 6
    Remove from heat and blend in vanilla extract. Stir CONSTANTLY until well blended and slightly warm and then pour into a prepared (baked) 9" pie crust.
  7. 7
    Top pie with meringue (recipe to follow).
  8. 8
    After meringue is spread on top, Bake at 350° for 12 to 15 minutes, or until meringue is golden. Cool for 10-15 minutes.
  9. 9
    MERINGUE: 3 egg whites (reserved from pie filling recipe), 1/2 teaspoons vanilla, 1/4 teaspoons cream of tartar, 6 tablespoons granulated sugar.
  10. 10
    With a mixer, beat egg whites with vanilla and cream of tartar until soft peaks form. Gradually add sugar, beating until stiff and glossy peaks form and all sugar is dissolved.
  11. 11
    Spread meringue over slightly warm filling, sealing to edge of crust. (Then bake and cool as directed above.).

Questions about this recipe?

Spot an error in this recipe?

Featured Reviews for This Recipe

From: Soozzee

On Oct 10, 2009

This pie was excellent! I made this today and my husband and I both love it. I did use dark brown sugar because that's all I had, otherwise, I made it exactly as written. I will definately be making this again as a pie and as a pudding, it was so creamy and smooth. Thanks for taking the time to share this wonderful recipe with us, Stacky5

0 people found this review helpful

  • Was this review helpful to you? YES | NO
  • From: flirtyfunchick

    On Aug 19, 2009

    I was looking for a butterscotch pie recipe to make for my husband's birthday and this is PERFECT! It is simple and quick to make. As he doesn't like meringue I baked the cooked pie crust with the filling as instructed, let it cool, then slid it into the fridge and topped it with whipped cream when I served it. This was a fantastic recipe - thank you so much for sharing!

    0 people found this review helpful

  • Was this review helpful to you? YES | NO
  • From: Mz Gig

    On May 26, 2008

    I wanted to make a butterscotch pie for my sister's birthday as it is her favorite. I have used regular pudding mix before, but wanted this one to be special. It was the BEST PIE WE HAVE EVER HAD! Easy to make, but tastes like it took all day and better than any high end restaurant could serve. Absolutely, positively, without a doubt, the best pie in the world. Thank you so much for the recipe!

    4 people found this review helpful

  • Was this review helpful to you? YES | NO
  • From: nursejillian

    On Oct 13, 2007

    okay, i made this for my father-in-law, and he gave this recipe 5 stars (i didn't rate it because i don't like butterscotch). He said this is just like his mom used to make! Thanks for making his birthday special!

    4 people found this review helpful

  • Was this review helpful to you? YES | NO
  • Read all 21 reviews

    Sister Sites: Food Network | HGTV | HGTVPro | DIY | Fine Living | Great American Country | FrontDoor.com Real Estate | Ecologue

    Comparison Shop for Kitchen Appliances & Utensils at Shopzilla & BizRate

    © 2009 Scripps Networks, Inc. All rights reserved